mon01 comments on their tutorials

I don't see much of these styles of animations anymore (and if I do on a website, I typically will move on quickly)...so am wondering about how useful this even is.

Pretty glossed over on the selection tools usage. Magic Wand is only really good for when you have definite differences between colors and tones. In most cases, it's not as hard and fast, and multiple selection tools are needed to get an accurate one. Also didn't see much mention of feathering. More details + fewer ads = better tuts

You really don't have to randomly insert "Photoshop tutorials" everywhere in your title or description.

The sunlight doesn't look very realistic as it is a brush with a few problems.

But the main aspect is tolerable.

real 3D :)

Sort of a rip from the actual DirectoryMix banner.

Not sure why this got a 0.5 rating.. it's certainly better than some other tutorials that were rated higher.

The URL needs to be fixed
http://photolearnsite.com/photoshop-learn-to-draw-effects/design-a-round-interface-button-idea-style

I notice you've added some detail to your tutorials, and changed the semantics some - very nice. The verbiage is much better and flows more easily this way.

404.

So ugly, stop rushing and add some details pls.

Very cool...great use of transform tool too!

Great tut and details...the only thing I'd like to see added are the gradient color values if I was working through replication.

Neat idea and a smooth, sharp implementation. Not sure I like the shiny glossy look, but that's just subjective.

Very nice outcome, love the reflection!

Pretty neat - would you mind sharing the color settings from your gradient overlay?

Nifty effect. =]

Nothing sets this tutorial apart from every other tutorial site that offers this same design.

This tutorial is a rip.

I believe this tutorial was rated so badly for a reason. It's just not properly explained.

When designing a business card, you're meant to work in millimeters at 300+DPI, not 200 x 100 pixels, or whatever. It's poorly designed.